Here's the concise, actionable 2025 outlook for Malik Nabers (NYG, WR1) based on the Reddit threads and FF Hound input you provided.

- 2025 fantasy role and upside
  - Likely weekly target driver if healthy and if he earns a clearWR1-type role on NYG; ceiling resembles a high-end WR2 with spike-game weeks in a plus Giants pass offense.
  - Rich Hribar’s takeaway (Antonio Brown-like upside) is the key sentiment driving his upside narrative. Safe floor is lower; big-boom potential exists if he commands 20%+ of targets and 2nd/3rd reads get open.

- Injury and availability risk
  - Camp/injury chatter: Nabers has missed time with a minor back issue (described as normal camp tightness); some chatter about toe/hip-type concerns and occasional turf/shoulder chatter elsewhere in mixed posts. Expect narrow early-season risk; monitor for practice updates.
  - Any actual decline in Week 1 readiness or early-season limitation could cap early-season output and push Nabers toward a slippery start.

- Offensive context and competition
  - Giants QB situation: Consensus noise suggests Russell Wilson as the likely Week 1 starter with Daniel Jones not in the mix; this is a stable but not explosive passing attack, which caps ceiling unless Nabers earns a true top-two target share.
  - Competition for targets: Posts imply relatively less competition for targets than some other WRs, but the Giants have emerging options; Nabers’ value hinges on earning a primary or near-primary target share rather than being a floor-rocket in a crowded room.

- ADP and sentiment signals
  - Market view: Nabers is being drafted around late 1st into early 2nd in many mocks, and in some auction dynamics he sits around high-end WR2 value (e.g., 8th in one mock). The room sees upside but remains wary of injury risk and offense ceiling.
  - General comp picks: Dave’s approach leans toward Nabers as upside at the end of a build, often alongside Nico Collins as a safe late-round target. The consensus sentiment is still “upside play,” not a lock-startable WR1.

- Draft strategy takeaways
  - If you can stomach the injury risk and the week-to-week volatility, Nabers is a strong late-round upside target or a best-ball stash.
  - Pairing strategy: consider Nabers with Nico Collins (as Dave did) or another mid-round target to mitigate risk and secure a high-upside pair.
  - In redraft, don’t reach; if Nabers slides, add him as a bench swing at the end of the draft, not as a starting-week-one anchor.
  - In auction formats, Nabers sits as a high-upside mid-range pick; use him as a value-target if his price remains reasonable relative to ceiling.

- When to move on Nabers in-season
  - If Nabers practices fully and shows a strong connection with Wilson early in camp/preseason, his likelihood of a solid target share increases; push him up slightly.
  - If back/toe/shoulder chatter persists or he misses multiple practices, treat him as risk-managed—prefer safer upside with a clearer path (e.g., a Nico Collins-type late-round pick) and avoid overpaying.

- Bottom-line verdict
  - Nabers is a high-upside, risk-adjusted play for 2025. He won’t be a safe week-to-week WR1, but in the right lineup (late-round add, or bench with weeks where Giants pass volume spikes) he can deliver league-winning upside. Monitor camp updates closely; his value hinges on securing a primary target role and staying healthy.